Herbert

    Scale

    9
    - April 28, 2017

    Calling something a return to form usually feels like a backhanded compliment. It generally implies that an artist has somehow lost his way, that the quality of his output lowered enough to be considered a slump. Or, the phrase can be used by a reviewer assuming the subtly egotistical role of the school teacher, rewarding the artist for getting back in line after misbehaving (encouraging the least risky music is as common a crime of this profession as it is of the charts).

     

    So instead of saddling Matthew Herbert’s Scale with the burden, let’s call his first straight-ahead dance record since 2001’s Bodily Functions what it really is: one of the best dance records of the decade. After his excellent big-band excursion with 2003’s Goodbye Swingtime, Herbert recorded Plat du Jour, an ambitious project that succeeded intellectually much more than musically. Scale is its superior for a number of reasons, not the least of which is that none of the anger and frustration with contemporary politics is missing; in fact, it comes over better on this record. On “The Movers and the Shakers,” Herbert’s long-time collaborator Dani Siciliano sings, “I just don’t know how to bring about your downfall/ damn fool/ go figure out/ how those Christian boys can orchestrate/ Shock and Awe.” Elsewhere, the record tries to make sense of a world where there is so much injustice. Yet none of it sounds preachy or obvious. Upon first listen, opener “Something Isn’t Right” seems like it’s about a relationship, but it could just as easily be about the state of the world.

     

    Musically, the record is a complete success. With heavy disco influences and none of the sappy deep-house vibe that made the second half of Bodily Functions (slightly) falter, the record rewards both the dance-floor crowd and the headphone geek. “Moving Like a Train” is straight old-school soul-inflected house with the strings to back it up. Every song is carefully structured and artfully arranged; even the six-minute sound collage of “Just Once” shimmers underneath the surface in a perfect tone.

     

    Herbert’s Scale is everything that was great about the disco underground: soulful vocals, progressive politics and smart party music. But it’s also very much a product of its time, both aware of its surroundings and focused on its influences. If it isn’t a major shift in dance music, it’s a perfect demonstration of the best the genre has to offer in 2006, bereft of the watered-down genre-bending that has, both positively and negatively, informed the past few years. A lean, focused record, Scale is Herbert’s best record to date, and a must-buy for any dance-music fan.

     

    Discuss this review at The Prefix Message Board   

    Matthew Herbert Web site

    Magic Accident Web site

    !K7 Web site

    Streaming audio

    SHARE
    Previous articleLa Revancha del Tango
    Next articlePoint