Mitt Romney's favorite band The Killers took to The Colbert Report last night to prove their assertion that "everyone likes [them]." Colbert certainly seems to like them, chatting up frontman Brandon Flowers and drummer Ronnie Vannucci Jr. about Mormonism, cleanly trashing hotel rooms, and confusing lyrics (Colbert: "You fucking with me, Brandon?"). Then the band stuck around to perform "Miss Atomic Bomb" off their new album Battle Born. But the highlight wasn't what was on the original broadcast: The Killers played Hot Fuss staple "All These Things That I've Done" as a web exclusive. Watch all three videos below.