Here’s the moment anyone who has been following this week’s showdown between Jack White and Stephen Colbert has been waiting for. The pair try to out-Catholic one another in the extended clip above, which pretty much follows the same line of banter the two have established over the past week. But the rest of White’s appearance on last night’s show featured White trying to turn Colbert into a rock star—“we’ve been through so much together,” the host says, when White shows up for a live appearance on the show. Colbert ultimately ends up performing a version of “Charlene II (I’m Over You)” with the Black Belles, which you can see below. Does he have what it takes to make a dent in the music world? Um, probably not, no.