Have you ever wondered where all those unwanted Last.fm scrobbles go to die? The social networking site’s “Most Unwanted Scrobbles” chart, which lists the top five artists and songs manually deleted from users’ listening histories, may ultimately be just as interesting as users’ official profiles:
Artists 1. [unknown] 2. The Beatles 3. Radiohead 4. Britney Spears 5. Avril Lavigne
On the artists side of the chart, The Beatles and Radiohead make sense -- users probably delete Kid A tracks en vrac to allow other, less-known artists to top their charts. But Britney Spears and Avril, along with pretty much all of the tracks, are grounds for some serious sociological speculating. There are guilty pleasures -- ones we admit to without compunction because, y’know, they’re funny or ironic -- and then there are tastes we would never admit to, for fear of utterly destroying our social being. Which are these? It makes one wonder what the list would look like if it were expanded.
It's funny what we attempt to hide... Maybe we can find a positive spin in all of this and hope beyond hope that people are moving on to better and different music (and not just Avril or Britney or Amy #2).
The poptimist in me wants to say that the deleted artists list is somehow "truer" than the profiles we actually present to our last.fm friends. But then again I love Britney and Avril unapologetically.
As if the stakes of profile purty weren't high enough...I guess the list indicates to me that "guilty pleasure" doesn't account for some of what's going on here. Cos you ultimately fess up to guilty pleasures, right? There's some stuff you listen to, though, that's verboten to even acknowledge. Like Death in June or P!nk.
That's pretty awesome that they unveiled this list. I'm actually surprised Radiohead isn't #1.
It's funny what we attempt to hide... Maybe we can find a positive spin in all of this and hope beyond hope that people are moving on to better and different music (and not just Avril or Britney or Amy #2).
The poptimist in me wants to say that the deleted artists list is somehow "truer" than the profiles we actually present to our last.fm friends. But then again I love Britney and Avril unapologetically.
They should release a list of the users who deleted Britney and Avril, just to call the guilty pleasure listeners out.
As if the stakes of profile purty weren't high enough...I guess the list indicates to me that "guilty pleasure" doesn't account for some of what's going on here. Cos you ultimately fess up to guilty pleasures, right? There's some stuff you listen to, though, that's verboten to even acknowledge. Like Death in June or P!nk.