Creative cripples MP3 players


[via Engadget]
I had a Creative Nomad Jukebox back in the day - it was as big and bulky as a CD player, but it had lots of nice recording features that only got better with successive firmware updates. Now, I'm no expert on technology (actually I am, but let's pretend), but generally firmware updates are supposed to add and update features, right?Well, Creative's latest updates for their Zen MicroPhoto and Zen Vision:M players remove FM recording capabilities. Those consumers that pick products based on a feature set will just have to live with one of those bullet points suddenly disappearing, I suppose. You can invent your own metaphor assuredly. Here's a few to get you started:

  • It's like ordering chicken and waffles, only to find Roscoe's ran out of waffles.

  • It's like having a CD player suddenly lose the ability to play artists whose names start with the letter "O".

  • It's like your cable company dropping Cinemax, while charging the same price and depriving you of the soft porn you so richly deserve.

  • It's like a respectable technology company reneging on a feature set that was promised to you in their asking price.


These developments against fair use are starting to pile up, and none of them favors the consumer. You can't record FM radio, you can't use the nifty portable TiVoToGo feature on new Series 3 devices, and if you have a dead grandmother, odds are the RIAA will be suing her next week. If you don't mind, I'm just going to break out my old cassette deck, record some college radio, and pour some beer on the corner for Nana, defendant in a suit still pending.
Note: You can see the MicroPhoto firmware for yourself here. The Zen Vision firmware disabling FM recording was pulled, according to some glitches according to Epizenter.
Posted in: CREATIVE , MP3 , MUSIC TECH
Stumble It!

9 Responses

October 17, 2006 at 12:32 a.m.

This is why I don't mess with firmware or software upgrades. Even with iTunes and AIM, I refuse to upgrade until I'm sure I don't lose something.

October 17, 2006 at 1:57 a.m.

What the heck happened to this site? It used to be a perfectly respectable and readable music site, until, of course, the Big Makeover. Now the site doesn't look like much and is chock-full of rather poorly written technology articles. Not my idea of fun. Please take action or you will lose at least this reader -- and a bunch of others, I'm sure.

October 17, 2006 at 8:15 a.m.

We still provide daily CD reviews, features and media. The only difference with the "Big Makeover" is that we now also provide news/blog entries. The CD reviews, features and media are still the same. We've just added more to the site. Also, the same people that write the other articles on the site also write on the blog.While you might be unhappy with the addition, I have trouble understanding your gripe because we still have the same sections that we had before. It's also safe to say that you're in the very tiny minority, I've only heard negative feedback from one person. Overall, our traffic (total visitors and return visitors) are up about 30% since the change. Granted not all of the increase is due to the changes, but there's now a reason to come back to the site throughout the day. P.S. The technology articles are one of the most popular additions to the site. P.P.S. What's with not posting your real name on your post? w.0. b.0. f.0.

October 17, 2006 at 12:05 p.m.

The Grumbler is a Republican. They dont like change so much.

October 18, 2006 at 2:47 a.m.

While The Grumbler appreciates the sly-ish aside, he is as far from a Republican as you can get.But what I don't understand is why I should've used my real name. What difference would it make, since the name would and could not ring any bells for you? Well, that's hardly the point.As far as the changes are concerned, I'm happy that everything's so peachy for you guys. Still, there's just so much blog-style content out there, I kind of liked the previous version better. A more organized front page might do the trick, though. Divide the articles by category, then place them in different part of the front page, for instance. And this is just a hunch, but I still feel the quality of writing has suffered somewhat.

October 18, 2006 at 6:44 a.m.

It's hard to take grumblings seriously from anonymous interent posters. Doesn't matter if I don't personally know you. It's incredibly easy to just criticize someone anonymously. Back to the redesign, so the feature is in the right column instead of the center of the page and the center is now filled with blog/news. There's also a ton of sites that do reviews and interviews. Like I said before, our visitors and return visitors are up so it seems like people like the changes. The CD reviews and features are still the same so just keep reading those areas if it's a major issue with you or just stop reading the site like you said you'd do.

October 18, 2006 at 11:07 a.m.

Here's my 2 cents on this. Grumbler, its no big secret that writing quality is taking a hit across the board when it comes to blogging and internet journalism. So do we fall under that category...yes. But so does every other site that is experiencing a modicum of success. The obsession on the internet currently is getting news as soon as it happens. That allows minimal time for the refinement of writing to come in. And if publications choose to spend significant time editing and refining, readers will go where they can get news sooner. Journalism/Publishing is an adapt or die industry and while I think this current incarnation of internet "journalism" is a fad, Prefix would not last to see the end of the fad if we didnt follow the trend to a certain degree.

October 18, 2006 at 10:20 p.m.

Creative won't even talk to Cnet about this:http://news.com.com/2061-10801_3-6127359.html?part=rss&tag=6127359&subj=news&tag=cnetfd.newssd.right

November 27, 2006 at 3:29 p.m.

[...] It’s only fair, since we covered Creative crippling some players’ ability to record FM, that we mention that they’ve brought it back with a new firmware update. It would be nice if they made any mention at all as to the reasons behind it; we can can surmise that it’s because the user backlash wasn’t worth the phantom risk of RIAA litigation, but Creative just announces firmware updates with a bullet list and little else. Creative has a good rep for enhancing the functionality of their players with firmware updates, but when one of those updates removes functionality, Creative risks whatever position they have in their niche spot behind Apple.            [...]

Add a comment


 

Prefix Logo

  Site Index RSS