News ·

Bobby Dylan, You Little Tramp

Sometimes album titles say it all. Sometimes they don't. And sometimes, Bob Dylan is involved, and all bets are off. Here's what we know in re Dylan's last three records. Time Out of Mind comes from "The Fall of the House of Usher." Love and Theft shares its name with that Eric Lott minstrelsy book that I've never read. And Modern Times, I'm guessing, is from the Chaplin movie (unless it's a Jefferson Starship reference, in which case Dylan is a more puzzling man than any of us can fathom).
Not too long ago I rented (Chaplin's) Modern Times on DVD (charging it to the Prefix expense account, of course -- cha-ching!) to see if there were any obvious or not-so-obvious connections between Dylan's new album and Chaplin's acknowledged masterpiece. The results of this little aesthetic experiment were, unsurprisingly, inconclusive. You kidding? This is Dylan, after all. Inconclusiveness and ambiguity and mystery are all part of the game. (On the new album, for example, he goes looking for Alicia Keys in Tennessee -- wha? -- and sucks the milk out of a thousand cows -- huh? -- and that's just on the first song.)
So, here's what I discovered about Modern Times the movie. First, if you haven't seen it, definitely add it to your Netflix queue. It's really funny and strange, and Chaplin is totally mesmerizing, possessing the greatest comic timing and most perfect facial expressions you'll ever see. The bit where he inadvertently puts "nose powder" in his soup is one of the most exceedingly precise bits of physical comedy ever filmed.
Second, Modern Times the movie ends with the tramp and the gamin walking off into the horizon, out of sight. On "Ain't Talkin'," the last song on Modern Times the album, Dylan sings of "walking till I'm clear out of sight." So there's that too.
Finally, and most significantly, is the movie's long, climactic café scene. Chaplin, in character as the "Little Tramp," is hired to sing in a café, only he can't remember the words to his song. His female companion -- the brains of the operation -- writes the lyrics on his shirt cuff. All good, right? Well, when the tramp goes out in front of the crowd to do his dance and sing his song, his shirt cuffs go flying off during a particularly exuberant dance move. Basically, at this point the tramp is fucked -- he can't remember the lyrics, he's in front of an increasingly antsy audience, and he needs this job, badly; it's the Depression and he's poor as shit. So what does he do? He makes up the lyrics, singing in a purely nonsensical mishmash of French, Italian, maybe some Spanish and definitely some plain-old gibberish. And the crowd loves it.
And 70 years later, Dylan names his album after that movie. Do you think the reason might be -- and again, I'm just speculating here -- but do you think Dylan might identify with the little tramp in that scene?
Zune - Microsoft offers MP3 player in 70's Brown Byron Crawford on Chuck Klosterman IV
Bob Dylan

With Joan Baez as the female companion? With Dylan singing gibberish? Astute observation.


or maybe he was a big fan of the modern lovers' song "modern world" and cheated it a little to make it more relavent for him. or could it be that he ran out of ideas when he felt like he was writing another "the times they are-a-changin'" and he thought "well, shit they done changed, they're modern now". or maybe he realized that his new new sound since "time out of mind" was pretty modern and that's what he's gonna do now till he dies. or maybe he just didn't care. i like any and all reasons. and i love how we try to breakdown the minds of those we see as creative geniuses especially when they say things that make little sense which are most likely just fucking with us to fuck with us.fuck, what was i talking about?

jack booty

Ozga, you're a bitch for not emailing me yet. Just sayin'.

Austin L. Ray

Buster Keaton>>>>Charlie Chaplin

Matthew Gasteier

Have you ever read Song and Dance Man III, Michael Gray's 900-plus-page deal that identifies specific songs, poems, movies, fairy tales, Bible passages, et cetera that may have influenced Dylan? Pretty incredible work. Modern Times isn't included (I think Time Out of Mind was the most recent album at the time of the last pressing), but maybe Gray will weigh in on it in the future.

Brandon Wall

Also, look what Motoko Rich had to say in the New York Times about the "strong echoes" in Modern Times' lyrics of poems written by Civil War-era poet Henry Timrod: Does Dylan get a pass because this type of songwriting is part of his, and folk's, tradition?

Brandon Wall

Find us on Facebook

Latest Comments