good list...i have the same one and two in reverse ordersonic youth, ghostface, yo la tengo should be higher...islands a little high for my tastemission of burma?
Nathan · 1:23 a.m. · December 13, 2006
Yeah, Mission of Burma was definitely talked about.
Dave Park · 1:27 a.m. · December 13, 2006
intriguing. Not what I was expecting. While the midlake album isn't entirely perfect, i thought maybe a spot at 49 , and beirut?Such is life. I Think that bonnie prince billy album is tremendously overrated and the less said about hold steady the better, but I seem to be alone on that one. Surprised not to see Yellow House place higher. IMO it's one of the more original and captivating albums of the year. Ys has nothing on it. An unpopular opinion, but still it's mine.
mama'sboy · 8:04 a.m. · December 13, 2006
nice job on the intro matt
ACB · 8:10 a.m. · December 13, 2006
between the site's list and the staff picks, this is a lot to take in at once. another bunch of great, overlooked records in an unexpected order. back-pats all around.more stuff i was surprised didn't make the cut: sunset rubdown, the coup, dabrye, lupe fiasco, the decemberists.
mason · 8:15 a.m. · December 13, 2006
The piece looks amazing. Can't believe Comets on Fire, Midlake, and Girl Talk didn't make the collective list.
John Zeiss · 8:19 a.m. · December 13, 2006
I'll take 5 out of 10...can't believe Lupe didn't make it tho.
Seth · 8:23 a.m. · December 13, 2006
mew!!! better than 90% of the stuff on here. just sayin.' and i second Midlake
ACB · 8:30 a.m. · December 13, 2006
girl talk was decent, but not good enough to make this list. not with the other albums that got cut.
Adrian Covert · 8:36 a.m. · December 13, 2006
"the less said about hold steady the better, but I seem to be alone on that one."no, you're not.
mason · 8:58 a.m. · December 13, 2006
Hip-Hop overrepresented? If it didn't seem so opaque, I would suggest spliting list into Top-Hop, Top-Everything else.Number formatting looks nice though.
Jason · 9:21 a.m. · December 13, 2006
Matthew Gasteier · 9:35 a.m. · December 13, 2006
Generalization.... Girl Talk = hip-hop for rock kids
Dave Park · 9:47 a.m. · December 13, 2006
Generalization: Dave Park = Bigot
Justin Sheppard · 9:52 a.m. · December 13, 2006
I don't think the Girl Talk record is horrible by any stretch. Overall, it's a little too "project-ey," but there's some interesting/great/fun stuff on there.
AJ Wolosenko · 10:55 a.m. · December 13, 2006
Props on the format and adding a sample track to each example. So The Roots and Yeah Yeah Yeahs albums were not among the year's 50 Best? But Nas' album was? That seems like kind of a slap in the face. Personally, I don't think Nas' album even belongs in the Top 10 Hiphop albums of the year. Disappointed nobody else mentioned The Walkmen but that's a personal preference. Clipse at #1 = How very Pitchfork of you.
BTW · 11:39 a.m. · December 13, 2006
"Clipse at #1 = How very Pitchfork of you."Because only Pitchfork liked Clipse this year...
Justin Sheppard · 11:49 a.m. · December 13, 2006
Georgia Anne Muldrow would have been my #11, so I'm glad at least one person put her on his list. Only one, though. Suprised Mission of Burma wasn't on more lists and that very few people seemed to like this year's Walkmen record, which really had some good songs on it. Ah well.
China · 11:51 a.m. · December 13, 2006
Why is it that when Pfork likes a record that every other site is trying to be like them?
Dave Park · 12:28 p.m. · December 13, 2006
Clipse at #1 = How very XXL of you.
Dave Park · 12:30 p.m. · December 13, 2006
I unlike the internet masses didn't really feel The Clipse album, but can't argue with the consensus. It did teach me how to cook and sell some bricks though.
Seth · 12:43 p.m. · December 13, 2006
both the walkmen and yeah yeah yeah's albums were good, but there were just more albums that were better. to quote the immortal billy bob thorton in bad santa, "they cant all be winners".
Adrian Covert · 12:48 p.m. · December 13, 2006
Where the hell is Mew? Islands and the Pipettes? Screw Pitchfork -the Pipettes suck. It's a very predicatable formula for your 1-10. Stick TV on the Radio right there at #2 but by no means give it #1...because honestly it's not likeable enough to be in the top 10. Neko Case? Another staple artist that looks great in the top 10. Oh, and how dare you NOT put Bob Dylan and Tom Waits in the top 10!!! Plus, Joanna Newsome -we all know that album is overrated but hey, everyone else loves it! And of course at #1, an album no one else will put there.I love you prefix!!!
Barrett Dire · 12:50 p.m. · December 13, 2006
I think everyone had Mew in 2005.
Dave Park · 12:58 p.m. · December 13, 2006
Vakill at #18 = how very ... unlike any other website with a year-end list.
mason · 1:08 p.m. · December 13, 2006
It's a crime not to have Lupe somewhere on this list... And the Joanna Newsom album is the most overrated and underwhelming album put out this year. Minor bitching aside, it's a pretty good list. Kudos prefixians!
J.P. · 1:14 p.m. · December 13, 2006
i haven't even heard half of our top 10. i am a bad music nerd.
Mike Krolak · 1:20 p.m. · December 13, 2006
er, i mean, i heard everything ever forever and this list is not mine so it's wrong!!
Mike Krolak · 1:21 p.m. · December 13, 2006
i didn't mind the girl talk record, but if that thing was in the top 50 i'd be annoyed.
Mike Krolak · 1:22 p.m. · December 13, 2006
you know, i could probably stand a little patience on hitting the 'submit' button.
Mike Krolak · 1:23 p.m. · December 13, 2006
There's really no convincing me that this flimsy ass Blow record was better than YYY's.
BTW · 1:32 p.m. · December 13, 2006
mew!!!! GLARINGIST OR ALL OMMISSIONS. upside your head daba. "I think everyone had Mew in 2005." u schtink. at least we can all agree that the images are the most beautiful things to ever grace teh prefix. also, micah p. hinson shoudl be on there somewhere. and xui xui record is g.0
ACB · 1:34 p.m. · December 13, 2006
OR = OF
Or the amateur hour that is Rhymefest over The Roots record...
BTW · 1:35 p.m. · December 13, 2006
Even Rhymefest over Lupe is an L.
kudos to staff for a great looking list, and a great intro from Matt.
Dominic Umile · 1:43 p.m. · December 13, 2006
Actually, I thought the blow record was far superior to the mediocre yeah yeah yeahs record.And that roots record was good, but not great, as was lupe, whereas the rhymefest record was interesting and superior lyrically.
Matthew Gasteier · 1:44 p.m. · December 13, 2006
I like the Lupe record, but it's quiet.The Blow record should have been higher.
Dave Park · 1:47 p.m. · December 13, 2006
and now its become okp hour here on prefix.
Adrian Covert · 1:47 p.m. · December 13, 2006
Worst list ever.Where the eff be the hip-hop? Where is Jeezy??????????????????Where is Jeezy??????????????????Where is Jeezy??????????????????Where is Jeezy??????????????????Where is Jeezy??????????????????Where is Jeezy??????????????????Where is Jeezy??????????????????Where is Jeezy??????????????????Where is Jeezy??????????????????Where is Jeezy??????????????????Where is Jeezy??????????????????Where is Jeezy??????????????????Where is Jeezy??????????????????Where is Jeezy??????????????????Where is Jeezy??????????????????Where is Jeezy??????????????????
Yung Daba · 1:48 p.m. · December 13, 2006
Fabulous intro... I like the list for the most partTom Waits is definitely deserving, and I'm not really upset to see Clipse at #1... I didn't have it in my Top 10, but different tastesGreat to see Man Man that high... Only surprises were that both The Elected and Josh Ritter didn't get on the list, seeing that they both got 8.0
davey t · 1:52 p.m. · December 13, 2006
Yeah the Mew record is so good it should be included in the top 50 for the next couple years...yo! It is a solid list -Junior Boys need to be much higher and Cat Power much lower. As for Bonnie Prince Bill, the guy is awesome...so you have to put him in your top 50 -or top 21, right? Even if that record is grossly overrated. It's like Mark Kozelek and anything he does -i don't care if he's covering GWAR, homeboy is always top 20. Which begs the question, where's his live album on this list? I know, I know...but still.Way to go guys -seriously, Prefix always has the overall best list.
Barrett Dire · 1:58 p.m. · December 13, 2006
No Sunset Rubdown makes me sad. Where are all the Bowie lovers ready to embrace their new king? Does no one else think its a better album than "Apologies to the Queen Mary" AND "Destroyer's Rubies"? Am I really all alone?
Jeff Klingman · 2:10 p.m. · December 13, 2006
Nice to see Final Fantasy and Destroyer represented. Canada keeps spitting them out. Discouraging to see The Strokes and Yo La Tengo. Ellos no tengo nada.You stuck belle and Sebastian in the very back seat didn't you? Very wussy. Why don't we trade seats with the TI album -or throw TI out? There, that's better.
Barrett Dire · 2:11 p.m. · December 13, 2006
Andrew you shut the HELL up about Xiu Xiu!!! For serious...
Justin Sheppard · 2:20 p.m. · December 13, 2006
woops, tienen, not tengo. It's sad not to see Beirut or Figurines. I'm very sad.
Barrett Dire · 2:30 p.m. · December 13, 2006
Some of you guys are acting like whiny babies. I've been trying to trade some of you guys to Stylus or Pfork but they ain't haven't it.
Dave Park · 3:19 p.m. · December 13, 2006
I'm getting drunk to deal
Yung Daba · 4:02 p.m. · December 13, 2006
It's definitely a list, I'll give it that. There's definitely some records on there that I will have to check out, and I think its pretty interesting to see so many hip-hop records alongside the indie jams...How exactly does a staff writer get his own Top 10?
Lars Garvey Laing-Peterson · 4:08 p.m. · December 13, 2006
dave park is the biggest whiny baby of all. so there. ::takes ball, goes home::i thought cat power and islands were way high, but i like that nas was up there. i just listened to that record on the way to work this morning...it is good. matt nailed it with the whole rapping while being an icon thing. nas is good.
mk · 4:09 p.m. · December 13, 2006
whatever MK. You're w.0.that Islands record is great. It just came out too early in the year.I like other Cat Power records more but I still dig the Greatest.Sub-par rapping from Nas is still better than 99% of the best stuff from the other rappers.
Dave Park · 4:16 p.m. · December 13, 2006
Lars,We sent out an email asking all you guys to submit your lists a few weeks back. If you want your list up, send it on over. Thanks!
Dave Park · 4:20 p.m. · December 13, 2006
i still hate nas' selection of beats.
Adrian Covert · 5:15 p.m. · December 13, 2006
Lupe Fiasco is a glaring omission. Pretty inconsistent since at the time, you guys called Food and Liquor the best hip-hop album of the year. Please tell me that was just a huge fuck-up on prefix's part.
AJ · 6:11 p.m. · December 13, 2006
me likey that beat on 'money over bullshit'.
mk · 6:48 p.m. · December 13, 2006
i think people make too much of nas beats. overall not great, but he's not picking total shit.
Matthew Gasteier · 7:26 p.m. · December 13, 2006
yes, but i hear songs like "if i ruled the world" or "nas is like" and wonder what an entire album of beats that match his flow would sound like. im excluding illmatic from this discussion, of course.
Adrian Covert · 7:31 p.m. · December 13, 2006
i hated about half the beats on the vakill record at first, but i think he's such a badass on the mic that he actually makes those beats awesome. i totally love them now. 'serpent & rainbow" = pretty cheesy but so so good.
mk · 8:50 p.m. · December 13, 2006
To me Loose Fur is a huge omission. As are albums by Sunset Rubdown, Glissandro 70, Feu Therese, Glenn Kotch, Wooden Wand, Six Organs of Admittance, OOIOO, David Pajo, Califone, Tortoise (Box set!), or anything avant-garde. I'm sorry, the Liars album does not count, its aweful!!!
J - Ro · 10:37 p.m. · December 13, 2006
I love how you cannot read a review of a Hip Hop album released in 2006 without the obligatory stabs at the genre as stale, misogynistic and thuggish and yet it is strongly represented in yet another year-end best-of.If people could pull their heads out of their asses they would see the genre is doing just fine.Not a stab at your prefix, but at hip-hop crit at large.Nice list by the way, although Lupe is noticeably absent.
Johnny · 1:35 a.m. · December 14, 2006
Guillemots - Through the Windowpane deserves much more attention, Junior Boys should be in the top ten.in response to the above post, i don't think anyone could claim hip-hop is stale, it's probably the most exciting and alive genre of music there is right now. but that doesn't mean there isn't a tremendous amount of misogyny surrounding it and within it, it's very possible to enjoy the music and be off-put by some of the lyrics or the videos. the complete objectification of women in your typical video and in many tracks - most vividly seen in the rampant association of the female body with cars - is a serious culture problem. the "truth" that makes hip-hop such a vital form of expression does not need to simultaneously idealize these hyper-male dehumanizing fantasies. it weighs even heavier on the mind when you are a fan of the music, i mean if fans and critics don't demand higher standards than things won't change. i love the clipse album and i realize that "dirty money" is part of creating a believable environment for the record, just like the coke references and the beats themselves, but that doesn't mean it can't also bother me that they perpetuate a huge inequality in our society that spreads beyond just hip-hop.
Imran · 3:00 a.m. · December 14, 2006
Any Top 50 albums of 2006 list without Califone's - "Roots & Crowns" is considerably flawed and your lack of that album seriously undercuts the legitimacy of the entire list.
matt · 1:27 p.m. · December 14, 2006
Good list, with lots of good records. But the lack of Decemberists and Midlake renders it meaningless, unfortunately.Serious question to the Prefix folks: Do you all seriously believe that "The Crane Wife" is not one of the 50 best albums released in 2006? This BOGGLES my MIND.
Harry Blazer · 1:05 a.m. · December 16, 2006
Great list. Great list! Originality over mass appeal.It's a refreshing change from the majority of the lists I've seen this year. It makes 2006 look exciting!
Mark Ogilvie · 7:15 p.m. · December 16, 2006
Thanks for the list, some great stuff on there that I missed. Going back to rock it out. Clipse album is solid, don't take any heat for putting it up so high.
Kyle · 2:32 a.m. · December 17, 2006
Harry, I can't speak for the entire Prefix staff, but I'm the one that wrote our review for "The Crane Wife," and I can tell you that I feel it's painfully overrated. The actual "Crane Wife" trilogy is pretty good, but outside that I find the album to be mostly just cookie-cutter indie pop. Perhaps, you could explain what makes this album so great and what makes our list meaningless without it. Honestly, I'm not seeing it.
Justin Sheppard · 10:10 a.m. · December 18, 2006
watsup no love 4 the juggaknots album Use Your Confusion, no where in sight 0-50, no wins ya'll aint got no love 4 BSlim/Queen Herawin, and the Brewin-shame,shame,shame
feverfunkman · 1:35 p.m. · December 19, 2006
I think the Cunninglynguists album should be on the list.
Daba · 2:38 p.m. · December 19, 2006
i liked use your confusion, but i think it suffers from the awesomeness of its forefather...kinda like how godfather part III, outside of sofia coppola's complete inability to act, is a pretty great movie, but it will never be regarded as such.
mk · 9:19 p.m. · December 19, 2006
I feel like the M. Ward album should have been higher. It's beautiful and timely as well as timeless (clearly, this makes no sense in writing, but those who've heard it can surely attest to this...). I think that Sunset Rubdown is much more important than say...the new Strokes album. And, can't you find room for the Crane Wife. It may not be as great as everyone says, but it's one of the best reviewed albums of the year as well as something it seemed (for a brief moment) everyone agreed on. That has to count for something.
M. Schmid · 1:23 a.m. · December 20, 2006
BTW, f*** you. you little trailer trash don't know shit bout hip hop. Real hip hop is a message from the hood to the media. Hip Pop is what u listen to. Hip Hop is different from Hip Pop. Nas does Hip Hop. the pretigeous magazine are naming Nas' album as the best album of the year. because it reminds people not to forget where hip hop came from. USA Today, named it # 1. Newstand #1. New York times #1. Allhiphop.com #1. So your opinion is stupid.
good listener · 3:40 a.m. · January 11, 2007