Shearwater's Jonathan Meiburg doesn't have the manic vocal drama of his Okkervil River bandmate Will Sheff. Where Sheff might build his smart aleck lyrics from whispers to a cathartic scream, Meiburg is content to simmer and spook in his high register all song long. "Rooks," the first song from the Austin band's June-scheduled album Rook, continues the lyrical bird fetish that lead former ornithologist Meiburg to name his band after a gull in the first place. The rooks here (as in European crows, not chess pieces) are in Hitchcockian quantites, though more disturbing than bloodthirsty as they drop dead from the sky blocking roads and choking normal life. Throughout, Meiburg seems collected and his music gentle; apocalyptic murmurs without accompanying booms. As the song progresses and the tension builds he leaves our plane entirely, unveiling a falsetto that's almost high beyond comprehension. He's transcended the grounded detail of the song's start and is already rising to rapture. And if that's the record's starting point, then we're going to need a few new synonyms for epic come July.
Shearwater
"Rooks"
Average Rating:
Shearwater's Jonathan Meiburg doesn't have the manic vocal drama of his Okkervil River bandmate Will Sheff. Where Sheff might build his smart aleck lyrics from whispers to a cathartic scream, Meiburg is content to simmer and spook in his high register all song long. "Rooks," the first song from the Austin band's June-scheduled album Rook, continues the lyrical bird fetish that lead former ornithologist Meiburg to name his band after a gull in the first place. The rooks here (as in European crows, not chess pieces) are in Hitchcockian quantites, though more disturbing than bloodthirsty as they drop dead from the sky blocking roads and choking normal life. Throughout, Meiburg seems collected and his music gentle; apocalyptic murmurs without accompanying booms. As the song progresses and the tension builds he leaves our plane entirely, unveiling a falsetto that's almost high beyond comprehension. He's transcended the grounded detail of the song's start and is already rising to rapture. And if that's the record's starting point, then we're going to need a few new synonyms for epic come July.
Posted in:
MP3
,
SHEARWATER
,
TRACK REVIEW
Rate this Track
Average rating:
9.0
Login to rate this post
More features, reviews, photos, mp3s, and video
Who rated this track?
5 Responses
February 28, 2008 at 12:30 p.m.
|
|
Shouldn't "Okervill Rover" be Okkervil River? Or am I missing some pun? PS: Shearwater is tops. |
February 28, 2008 at 12:31 p.m.
|
|
btw. good track review Jeff. |
February 29, 2008 at 11:26 a.m.
| Sally |
Glad to see Shearwater here, but you might want to listen to some more tracks by the band; Jonathan Meiburg is a master of what you term |
June 16, 2008 at 1:40 p.m.
| Zimmy |
Okkervil River are (with possible exception of Sparklehorse) my favourite band on the planet. Just listened to Rook by Shearwater for the first , and 2nd, 3rd, 4th, 5th etc time. Wow, haunting, desolate, poetic and loads of other great things too. May have to re-evaluate the order of things. |
Shearwater »

just saw Meiburg last night with Callahan. He was pretty fantastic. But he sounds alot better with a band behind him. Really like this track.